Could you imagine anything worse than being forced to spend your long-awaited Christmas holidays with your cantankerous and condescending class teacher? Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa) certainly can’t in Alexander Payne’s quaint and charming dramedy, The Holdovers. Set in 1970-1971, it follows Paul Hunham (a consistently funny Paul Giamatti), a Classics teacher with a lazy eye who often delights in handing out poor grades to his unenthused “delinquents”. However, the only student he rewards a respectable grade to is Mr. Tully, a noticeably intelligent but frustratingly wayward teenager who’s left with Mr. Hunham during the school break because his mother wants to go on her honeymoon with Angus’ new stepfather. While a cranky, middle-aged educator and an unruly adolescent may not initially appear to have much in the way of commonalities, their dynamic, of course, blossoms into an amiable, albeit still deeply sarcastic, friendship that simply cannot be resisted, even if it is a tale as old as time.
Perhaps their relationship becomes more pleasant thanks to Mary (stunningly performed by Da’Vine Joy Randolph), the school cook who recently lost her son, Curtis, in the Vietnam War. Her grief encourages the two bickering men to put their petty differences into perspective and realise that, while their situations over the festive season are not ideal, there are people behind closed doors who are going through the unimaginable. Mary really is the heart of this story; there’s one scene where she visits her pregnant sister which is one of the most subtly heart-breaking moments to come out of Payne’s film. Once Mary begins to let her guard down emotionally to Hunham and Tully, the mood in the story slowly but surely begins to shift. What follows is an often sombre (but still highly comical) series of events that’s sure to make The Holdovers a staple to watch during the winter months.

The film is carried by the three central performances from Giamatti, Joy Randolph, and Sessa; without strong acting from the trio, this all could’ve easily fallen apart. Luckily, Paul Giamatti can always be relied on. Sardonic in the most beautifully passive-aggressive manner, his portrayal of Hunham is nothing short of iconic. It’s easy to imagine him going down as one of the most celebrated film teachers of the 21 st century, similarly to Robin Williams in the 1980s with his character in Dead Poets Society. Then you’ve got Joy Randolph, who’s brilliant at allowing both Giamatti and Sessa to show off their comedic capabilities while simultaneously humbling their characters with Mary’s mature, no-nonsense perspective. There’s so much going on with her eyes; even though her character does not shy away from her son’s death, it feels like there’s still a lot left unsaid, purely because she simply can’t bring herself to talk about it all. Sessa, meanwhile, is an acting newcomer, and what a remarkable debut performance he delivers. Often a smirking figure and a frequent know-it-all, Angus Tully never becomes unpleasantly smug or unlikeable. From the very beginning, it’s only natural to gravitate towards his unsure, slightly awkward demeanour; he often looks like a lost little boy inside a grown man’s body. Wait for one exchange in particular between Tully and one of his family members; it’s amongst the most heart-dropping moments in the film, and Sessa is never better than he is in this understated interaction with someone his character holds dear.
The Holdovers also features a grainy filter throughout that wonderfully emulates 70s aesthetics. Rather than being an imitation of films from decades before, it actually feels like something released within that very era. This provides Payne’s comedy-drama with a great sense of authenticity that you don’t often find in modern cinema or TV. The direction by Payne, meanwhile, is rightly simple, ensuring that the focus isn’t pulled away from the performances and narrative, which are the two components that drive The Holdovers so brilliantly. Flashy direction simply isn’t required in a film that contains one of the most amusing chase scenes to come out of the silver screen in a long time, as well as one of the most sincere and heartfelt handshakes between two characters, which was more moving than many onscreen hugs and kisses.

Payne’s latest directorial work certainly doesn’t break much new ground, but what it lacks in originality is made up for by the unforgettable main performances, its cuttingly humorous script (Giamatti delivers an insult so satisfyingly brutal towards the end of the story that it’s almost wheeze-worthy), and the enjoyable friendships that are formed along the way. Destined to be a Christmas classic? I think so.



























